Por Nick Estes
![]() |
Wildfire smoke and the horizontal drill pad for the Line 3 crossing at the Red Lake River (August 2021) |
The first time I heard “Minnesota Nice,” it struck me as one of those cynical regional euphemisms, the way “Southern Hospitality” belies a sordid inheritance.
It was late summer 2021 in Northern Minnesota. We had driven twenty hours or so from New Mexico to the resistance camps established directly in the pathway of the Line 3 pipeline. Our hosts called this place the “Deep North,” another coy understatement for something more sinister—a region where polite smiles and “All Are Welcome” yard signs coexisted with Thin Blue Line flags and militarized county sheriffs armed with tear gas and rubber bullets.
Line 3 was itself a deception of sorts. Enbridge, the Canadian energy company building the pipeline, had billed it as a “safety” replacement project to maintain the integrity of corroded pipes after a half-century of operation. Opponents saw that rhetoric as little more than a smokescreen. The expansion project increased flows of tar sands crude from Alberta to Wisconsin and effectively served as a reroute for the Keystone XL Pipeline, which a coalition of Indigenous nations and environmental groups had recently defeated.
But the fate of Keystone XL would not be the same for Line 3. For starters, unlike Keystone XL, which mostly crossed pipeline-friendly red states, the most contested leg of Line 3 cut across an ostensibly “pro-environment” blue state. Opponents cited a figure that Line 3 would unleash greenhouse gas emissions equivalent to fifty new coal-fired power plants. And whereas Keystone XL had united the Oceti Sakowin nations standing in its path, only three of the seven impacted Ojibwe tribes in Northern Minnesota opposed Line 3, hardly a united front even with the support of environmental groups. Those in opposition, including a vocal group of Ojibwe people sometimes standing against the acquiescence of their own tribal governments, cited the violations of treaties and the existential threats to land, water, and Manoomin (wild rice).
Even without the addition of the new pipeline’s carbon footprint, the land was already reeling from warming temperatures bringing on a historic drought. Lakes shrank back from their docks, leaving stranded piers jutting over cracked mud. Rivers and creeks dried up. Along exposed riverbanks, thousands of freshwater mussel carcasses baked in the sun, creating a cemetery of white shells dotting the shoreline. The heat and lack of flow had sucked the oxygen from the water, slowly suffocating creatures known to live up to a century.
I have a recurring and haunting nightmare of a crying woman. Searching for the sound of the wails, I’m unable to locate the person in distress or what or whom she is mourning. One morning, however, the sounds were very real. The leader of our camp stood knee-deep in the river, softly weeping by herself. Around her floated lifeless white shells, a silent massacre whose heaviness few registered. Less than a hundred yards upstream, the diesel engines of idling excavators rumbled as a crew in yellow hi-viz vests prepped heavy machinery to drill under the river.
At a different location, massive horizontal directional drills sat idle, poised to bore beneath a riverbed that had shrunk into a shallow mud puddle. The surrounding soil had baked into hard, crumbling clods. We walked to another pipeline construction site past rows of “pineapple corn,” another new word for me—heat-stressed and dehydrated corn plants that tightly roll their long leaves inward, taking on the spiky resemblance of a pineapple.
Wildfire smoke from Canada blanketed the land. The first time it appeared one morning, I mistook it for fog. Its burnt-plastic and sour odor brought on coughing fits, a fever, and a respiratory infection that stuck with me for weeks after the journey into the Deep North. The dark, orangish-red sunrise and sunset caught in the grayish-white atmosphere made Earth feel like it was orbiting a different star, or that we were on a different planet entirely.
Everything around us was dying. But there is always a reason behind tragedy.
Despite the lack of rainfall, sticky humidity hung thick through the dog days of the Minnesota summer. Tuning into local radio stations gave the jarring impression that everything wasn’t just normal—we were on the precipice of an economic boom. Enbridge ads played between country and classic rock songs, upbeat narrators touting a familiar refrain about the benefits of pipelines: jobs. The company promised thousands of temporary construction positions, alongside a secondary wave of hospitality work at restaurants and hotels to serve the influx of new workers.
It was a boom-time economy, we were told. And the prophets of prosperity weren’t leading us to the new promised land—that had already been taken and received. Instead, they offered the promise of a new era of economic upturns in a region that had long experienced downturns. Besides the scenic lakefronts and resort towns, much of white rural Minnesota is losing population. The flight of the young for the far-off promises of city life has hollowed out the agricultural towns that defined settler culture for more than a century, leaving behind boarded-up storefronts, shuttered schools, and aging grain elevators. Desperate boosters clung to pipeline dreams of turning around the local economy.
This is a familiar narrative in which Indigenous peoples, despite settler myths of their disappearance, have played an active role in building the region’s labor force and creating its working class.
When the colonizers came, the “labor market” wasn’t a terra nullius—or rather terra sine labore (a land without toil). The once-vibrant modes of production that did not have at their center the profit motive, but rather the aspiration of living in correct relations with the land and all that lived upon it, formed the base of many of these societies. From that base arose the superstructure of culture, laws, language, and customs—remnants of which still endure today, even after subsistence economies tied to harvesting plants like wild rice and hunting animals like buffalo were annihilated. Embedded within the two predominantly spoken Indigenous languages in Mni Sota Makoce today, Dakota Iapi and Ojibwemowin, are the value systems and ethics of a non-capitalist world—a world that required work and labor to sustain correct relations with the land, alongside stories and myths that encouraged one to live in good relations. It was a world in which humans were often the most pitiful creatures because of their hubris, physical weaknesses, and complete dependency on all living beings. In other words, the world that existed before and concurrently with extractive economies was one in which humans were either equal to or below all other living things, requiring a kind of humility in the labor and pursuits of the mind and spirit that always centered relations outside of oneself and human societies with what one might call today the natural world.
Just as Europeans didn’t bring land with them, they also didn’t bring the concept of labor or work. In fact, many enslaved others to do the work for them or exploited existing labor relations in the new land. Those first “jobs” were often bound up in extraction, whether in the fur trade or mining. European men in the fur trade frequently exploited existing Indigenous kinship networks by “marrying” or “buying” Native women, becoming “squaw men,” a racist and misogynist term with origins in one of America’s original extractive industries. In other words, early capitalist industries relied heavily on the kinship-based labor networks that had developed and lived with this land for millennia, before doing away with them entirely once they became redundant or turned into obstacles to subsequent extractive industries like timber, iron mining, and industrial agriculture.
Once the fur trade annihilated the fur-bearing animal populations in the pursuit of profits, there emerged a trader class, selling on credit highly valued goods such as gunpowder, cloth, and cookware, alongside the essentials no longer available on the land: food. The effects were devastating, transforming once-sustainable economies into economies of dependency. Many of the traders who indebted Indigenous nations also became the brokers of treaties, oftentimes becoming signatories alongside U.S. military commanders and leaders of Indigenous nations. The treaties often guaranteed federal buyouts of accrued Indigenous trade “debt.” And the traders themselves frequently became the early ruling economic and political class on the frontier, whose names dot the landscape as a reminder of their historical importance in securing a settler future.
More than a century and a half later, the script remains largely unchanged. Today’s brokers arrive not with ledgers of debt and barrels of pork and gunpowder, but with radio spots, tribal buyout offers, and the polite, smiling veneer of “Minnesota Nice”—masking the same old bargain of short-term jobs in exchange for a permanent state of ecological destruction.
To be continued…
This piece first appeared on Nick’s Substack.
Nick Estes is a citizen of the Lower Brule Sioux Tribe. He is a journalist, historian and co-host of the Red Nation Podcast. He is the author of Our History Is the Future: Standing Rock Versus the Dakota Access Pipeline, and the Long Tradition of Indigenous Resistance (Verso, 2019).

Nenhum comentário:
Postar um comentário